Jump to content

williewonka

Central Alberta Member
  • Posts

    310
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by williewonka

  1. the feeding well isnt completely true. Williewonka does feed his piranhas well.

    I thought the same thing. Until i saw the violent attack of the one piranha that he talked about.

    I literally screamed. in less then a few seconds half his body was gone.

    i would think that its kind of like you never know.

    They could be fine. They could not be fine.

    If you want to take that chance.

    i kept these guys well fed and i would put my hands in the water. the never seem to even try to attack..

    I fed these guys all they wanted daily too. And, being so skittish, I have no problem putting my hand in the tank with them anytime (although I'm hesitant to do it with the elong). I'm just saying that I wouldn't put any fish that I really cared about keeping in with them. After what they did the last time I increased the temperature to let them breed, I'm not sure I want to let them do it again. Even though, all last summer two pairs were nesting on average twice a week for 4 or 5 months with no problems. Not even fin nips. But, I guess all fish, like people, are different and yours were compatible. He might be lucky too, and have it last.

  2. When I had rbps I bought a bunch of feeder goldfish at the same time. In with the goldfish was a jewel cichlid. The rbps were fry and all the feeders were about the same size. As the rbps grew so did the cichlid.

    They lived for about 5 years together. Then one day I came in the house and all that was left was the jewels head. So it is possible to keep some things with rbps, but I wouldn't recommend it.

    Brad

    Sort of what I was trying to say. I had two breeding pairs in the tank and no injuries while they were breeding but one day boom...The fifth one was gone. I also have a pleco in with them for almost a year and they don't seem to bother it, but, I'm pretty sure that it will one day be food also.

    Fred

  3. Maybe for a while... but not long term. Piranha have a habit of eating their tank mates , even other piranha. I had 5 around the 8 inch mark in a 120 gal for close to a year. Then in a matter of 30 seconds or so, I had 4 and one with the back end gone. I had to put that one down. Right now, I have one in a qt tank with a one inch bite out of it's side. So, I'd say any fish I cared about, I wouldn't put in with a piranha. Although, you never know, the two oscars might take out a solitary piranha. Either way though, you'd be out a fish.

  4. Couldnt you just put a divider in the tank with the female in it? Seems to me this would be better as the female would be less stressed by leaving her in the exact same water...

    Question! After you notice a female cichlid holding, How many days before you take action to try and save the little ones from certain cannabalism?? Does this depend on Species? I have Pseudo Saulosi and Flametail breeding groups. Do you seperate that female and make her cough them up into a breeding net?? I need some advice on the best way to do all this breeding stuff, I already have some growout tanks for the fry.

    Say if you did put a divider into the tank. Would it be of any benefit at all if you had two females holding and you put them both in together with the males separate? Thanks

×
×
  • Create New...